Best Friends Blog

Michael Vick and the Virginia Tech Sports Hall of Fame

Meryl the Vicktory dogOn July 11, Michael Vick was selected to be inducted into the Virginia Tech Sports Hall of Fame, based on his extraordinarily successful sports career at that school.

Understandably, many have come out against giving such an accolade to Vick, a convicted felon involved in horrific animal abuse. I agree and believe that the university is only sullying its reputation by bestowing such an honor on him. As of this writing, more than 60,000 petition signers on agree.

However, Best Friends may have a different take on Michael Vick than many.

As I’m sure you know, Best Friends took in the 22 most challenging canine victims of Vick’s Bad Newz Kennels dogfighting operation, following the highly publicized bust in April 2007 and the subsequent federal trial. The trial landed him in Leavenworth on a plea bargain for racketeering charges related to “Conspiracy to Travel in Interstate Commerce in Aid of Unlawful Activities and to Sponsor a Dog in a Fighting Venture.”

We called them the Vicktory dogs and their story has been documented here and in the award-winning film The Champions.

We are well acquainted with their physical and emotional scars and the fear that haunts some to this day. Other dogs at Bad Newz Kennels never made it out alive. There are a lot of reasons to want to further punish Michael Vick and to work to make sure he never gets beyond the stigma of the label “dog killer.”

I believe, however, that we need to free ourselves of the Michael Vick obsession.
Hatred poisons the hater.

The basic founding principles of Best Friends are follow the golden rule (Treat others as you would want to be treated) and relate to animals, people and the world around us with kindness. They are the ideals we strive to keep, and we measure the effects of our work and ourselves against them. It may sound rather “pie in the sky,” and we miss the mark sometimes, but we do have a mark.

Likewise, the no-kill movement is grounded in the same principles — that the lives of homeless pets have intrinsic value and we should treat the animals with the same respect that we would hope to receive and work to give them every opportunity to live and thrive, as we desire for ourselves. Our movement is not built on vindictiveness or revenge. Some no-kill messengers are perceived as wanting to treat shelter workers as many want to treat Michael Vick. If those motives contaminate our work, then we are simply creating enemies rather than building alliances, and making it harder to reach the day when no-kill practices are universally embraced. Kindness and the golden rule should apply to how we treat one another, not just the animals.

As for Michael Vick, I have many better things to do with my time and attention than to follow him or track his life at this point. If this latest episode had not been brought to my attention, I would likely have missed it. He will never receive the legal punishment that I, and many others, believe he should have received at the time, but his conscience is surely a lonely prison. We don’t need to waste our energy reinforcing his punishment.

Michael Vick in his prime was a supernormal athlete with virtually unlimited potential. He was the golden child of professional football and, at one time, the highest paid NFL player in history. The wealth, fame and public acclaim that he sought, and which he briefly held, turned to dust in his hands.

Michael Vick knows that. He knows what he squandered. He knows what cruelty cost him. He knows what he lost, how he is regarded, how his children will have to bear his cross. He will always know that. He knows that for most of the world, he is not the sport hero on the Olympus of athletics that his talent seemed to pre-ordain. He is just Michael Vick, the felon.

Should he be inducted into the Virginia Tech Sports Hall of Fame or any other hall of fame? No. Do I care? No, I don’t. We have much more important things to think about than Michael Vick. Things like rallying the country to end the killing in shelters by 2025 with kindness and compassion.

Together, we will Save Them All, while Michael Vick will live what remains of a life that could have been so much more.

Love reading the Best Friends Blog? Make sure you never miss a post by clicking here to subscribe and receive every post right in your inbox.


Gregory Castle
CEO Best Friends Animal Society

  • Jan Hogan

    Thank you for that post. I like many others do not like Michael Vick. Has he paid the price for what he did ?… NO… and many believe he never will. I just read your article on Willy Boy and cried. Hating what had happened to him because of Vick. I have seen the Champions, read almost every book written about the dogs. I wondered when reading the above article if Vick ever read some of these same books or articles.. I think not. It amazes me all these years later that reading that one of these dogs has died upsets me so. I also wonder why I waste my time and thoughts on this man. He does not deserve any of these accolades. I think what bothers me most is.. does he even “GET IT” about what he did?? You are correct.. we can only wonder what goes through his mind. What I can’t understand is that the NFL, Virginia Tech, Fox, and the other companies who seem to have disregarded the fact he is a convicted felon, give him these jobs, and awards.. So, who should we be mad at??? That is sad..
    I thank Best Friends for bravely taking the 22 dogs they did. It was an “unknown” back then if they could be saved… I am so glad they were.

  • Allyson Mcphaul

    Just heard Michael Vick will be announcing for Fox Sports. Great, if we want to watch football, we will not only have to think about him but see him too. Right in our faces. So NFL football will not be allowed on our tv. And I agree with spookydog19.

  • Betty Murphy

    Very well said. It is difficult for me to erase the image of what Vick did to those beautiful dogs and how they suffered. He will have to answer to a much higher power one day.

  • Laurie Collins

    This issue is not about Vick. Or harboring hate and revenge against Vick. Or turning the other cheek. It is about the message Virginia Tech. is sending – that egregious animal cruelty is not on its list of dishonorable conduct. Would the school have made the same decision if Vick had committed a heinous crime involving a human? Best Friends probably has many good reasons for taking the position it has taken. We should be grateful though for the person who took the time to start the petition and those who signed it. The message the petitioners are sending is that animal cruelty will not be tolerated.

  • Gerry

    Let me start by saying how much I admire Best Friends. But choosing to voice a protest against Vick being given a position of honor is not about revenge or hate or an inability to move on. It seems to me that allowing it to happen without speaking up is to turn ones back on the rights of all living beings. Black, white, brown; Jew, Christian, Muslim; human or animal; we all have the right to life. When someone is persecuted, we need to respond to that injustice. That is not vindictiveness against the prosecutor, it is compassion for the victim. When you speak about Vick being imprisoned by his conscience, where is the evidence of this? Does a man who kills his children’s pets have a conscience? Is he capable of understanding what he has done to others? Or does he only repent for what he has lost? Now that he has everything back again, what lesson have we all learned? This is not about Vick. This is about an institute of learning choosing to emulate victory over humanity. Let them give the award to someone who deserves it; someone who is “tackling” the plight of animals largely due to human folly. Let them give the award to Best Friends.

  • Terri Strang


  • Lynda Roth

    I have no hatred toward Michael Vick. But, I will never forget what he did. I still believe that we send the wrong message to children when we reward felons with any type of reward. Colleges should represent higher standards.There are so many individuals who are more deserving of this sports award.

  • Kim Traugott

    What disturbs me is that the NFL and the people that love it seem to have little problem with players who abuse dogs or women, but a man who “takes a knee” for a cause he believes in can’t seem to find a job. Albert Einstein said, “The world is a dangerous place, not because of those who do evil, but because of those who look on and do nothing.”

  • Jillian

    It is always difficult to let go of anger when you know that the anger you hold is so justifiable. And yet, as so many others have said, you are completely correct. Continuing to build anger at events over which we have no control will not solve problems, while focusing that same emotion towards an attainable goal in which you can make a difference is a beautiful thing. Like you, I would not have even known about this recent event if I hadn’t heard of it here. I have to make the conscious choice to know what he did was unacceptable while remembering that continuing to think of him doesn’t do anything. Thank you for this post. It is an inspiring article of focusing your efforts and emotions on that which can make a difference rather than tormenting yourself by ruminating on that which you hate but can’t change.

  • Kariina Kelson

    Thank you, Gregory. Holding hate and resentment is like drinking the poison, hoping the other person dies…….

  • John L

    Well said….

  • Mary Jo Pickett

    I saw Champions and I bought the DVD. I laughed and cried. I hated MV all over again. While I try not to think of him, it is difficult. I have seen so much crap through out my life about the abuse of innocents, I cry my eyes out. Those poor dogs have found their places in my heart forever. The horrible pain and suffering they endured! When ever I hear his name, it makes me sick to my stomach! Therefor Gregory Castle I will agree, he isn’t worth thinking about, period. What is worth thinking about is how BEST FRIENDS rescued 22 of those precious dogs and made them CHAMPIONS! Thank you and God Bless

  • Dog Mom

    Your post made me think of 2 people I’ve encountered; they each started successful rescue groups, and saved thousands of dogs and cats between the two of them. Yet both organizations ultimately disbanded, in no small part due to how these two as directors alienated people – foster parents, volunteers, adopters, donors – by too often simply not being kind and respectful. Without a doubt these two individuals saw more than their share of human cruelty. But in the end an inability to be kind thwarted their effectiveness and sadly the real losers were the many more animals who could have been helped by their otherwise amazing efforts and dedication. It is HARD to be kind and forgiving; thanks for reminding us how necessary it is!

  • spookydog19

    I can advocate for animals and still hate Vick. And I do…

  • Norma Stevlingson

    A thoughtful posting for which I thank you. I still have negative feelings about Michael Vick, but I do not think about him and his deeds often unless something reminds me. I thank God and Best Friends for helping his dogs, and I continue to work for the animals in my corner of the world.

  • Francine L

    I’m one of the people who had a knee-jerk angry reaction to this accolade for Michael Vick. After reading your post and some soul-searching, I’ve been swayed to let the anger go. I’m still disgusted tat the Virginia Tech Hall of Fame is inducting Vick, but that’s on them. Bless BEST FRIENDS for saving Vicktory 22. And bringing awareness to the cruelty of dog fighting, even in the most affluent neighborhoods. Based on the big-hearted approach to these abused dogs, and educating us that they have a chance at rehabilitation, I think and hope that more people will be prompted to report sooner when they suspect this may be happening.

  • Maureen Curry

    Well said Gregory, thank you………

  • B.j. Taylor

    Very well said, Gregory. You’ve helped me a lot today.

  • Evelyn

    Wow!! Is that how you can get thru each day w/ what you see?? I thank you from the bottom of my heart for showing us just that. Your thoughts. You are so right. So right. He is less than ZERO!!!
    The most important thing is clearing the shelters, the killing of these innocent wonderful creatures who love us unconditionally……….
    Thank you❤️

  • Catherine Greenfield

    Thank you for the well reasoned and thoughtful post. It is time to move on from Michael Vick. Our animal friends our better served when we humans work together with kindness and patience.