Best Friends Blog

“I’ve made up my mind. Don’t confuse me with the facts.”

Be open to lifesaving ideasWe’ve talked about some “controversial” topics in past blogs. My July post on open adoptions caused a bit of a stir among many of you. Any time we write about some of the more progressive programs across the animal welfare movement, we tend to see two general kinds of responses. One group generally applauds the new data and the new way of thinking that can help save more lives. The other group digs in and simply denies the possibility that the new information could be correct. Why is that?

The Humane Research Council (HRC) just posted this blog about a phenomenon known as the “backfire effect.” The information feels very timely for this moment in animal welfare, when a new data-driven paradigm is changing long-held beliefs and sending lifesaving rates to all-time highs.

Programmatic changes and promotions such as fee-waived adoptions and open adoptions are two examples that have helped move animals out of shelters and into homes quicker than ever before. The research is very clear on both of those items. The amount paid for an animal as an adoption fee has nothing to do with how loved the animal will be. Regarding open adoptions, there’s little evidence to show that such pet placement policies result in higher returns than those involving an exhaustive, hassle-filled adoption process in which would-be adopters are made to feel guilty of poor pet parenting until they prove themselves worthy. Such restrictive or “closed” adoption policies, of course, move fewer animals into homes, meaning that more animals will be killed in the shelter.

So, when this new data-based evidence is presented, why does a group hold on to those deeply held beliefs, even though they may not be based on facts or may be just plain wrong? According to the HRC, there are a few reasons. The first, they say, is probably the most obvious — that we don’t like to be wrong. Who does — especially concerning practices with which we are comfortable?

Another reason, HRC says, is that once we internalize a belief, it’s hard to let that belief go. Rescuers invest a lot of trust in these decisions, which are difficult to step away from. And, maybe the most applicable reason for our field, we often let our emotions decide instead of our brains — especially for issues we care deeply about.

With about 9,000 animals killed in U.S. shelters each and every day, we need to be open to new ideas that may run opposite to what we believe to be true. More important, the animals depend on us to be open to them, because they are the ones dying in shelters when simple acceptance of new ways of thinking, innovative programs and progressive policies could save their lives.

Together, we can Save Them All if we don’t allow ourselves to believe that we have nothing left to learn about saving lives.

Love reading the Best Friends Blog? Make sure you never miss a post by clicking here to subscribe and receive every post right in your inbox.

Francis Battista
Best Friends Animal Society

“Get out of jail free” card for cats passed by Arizona legislature

Thanks to new legislation, free-roaming cats in Arizona can avoid the mandatory time hold at shelters and instead be quickly fixed, vaccinated and returned.

Read More »

A nod to the innovator of our era, the father of the no-kill movement retires

Father of the no-kill movement Rich Avanzino‘s innovative thinking and business sense, from the San Francisco SPCA to Maddie’s Fund, transformed animal welfare.

Read More »

Declaring a victory for community cats

Community Cats Projects in Albuquerque and San Antonio have set a new standard for feline sheltering procedures, improving the live release rate to 90 percent.

Read More »

Katrina: How the no-kill philosophy came to disaster response

Same commitment to no-kill principles that drove Best Friends’ animal rescue efforts following Hurricane Katrina continues with today’s work to Save Them All.

Read More »

Eight reasons to attend this year’s Best Friends National Conference

Best Friends’ 2015 National Conference in Atlanta, expected to be the biggest and best ever, offers an inspiring and uplifting place to learn to Save Them All.

Read More »

Want to help Save Them All? Talk to 10 friends today.

Share your passion for Best Friends and saving lives, and turn your friends into supporters just like you, by recruiting others to Save Them All.

Read More »

The absurdity (and tragedy) of breed-discriminatory laws

After her pit bull terrier saves her from an abusive boyfriend, woman is forced to rehome her dog because of a breed-discriminatory law.

Read More »

Badges? We don’t need no stinking badges.

Since 1984, Best Friends has advocated the no-kill message and that effort continues at the 2015 Best Friends National Conference from July 16-19 in Atlanta.

Read More »

A “leftover dog” becomes my guide dog

Dog from a Los Angeles super adoption 15 years ago offers a unique perspective in getting what he wants and connecting to humanity.

Read More »